Architect-Led Project Management vs Design and Build - Project London

Who is on your side? Architect-led project management vs design and build

Every renovation involves three roles: designing the home, building it, and checking that the work and the costs match what was agreed. The route you choose decides who fills each role, and whose interests they represent.
Share

Design and Build

Under design and build, a single main contractor assumes responsibility for both the design and construction of a project. The contractor may use its own designers, appoint external consultants or take on designers originally appointed by the client through a process known as novation.

The appeal is clear. There is a single contractual point of responsibility and often an agreed lump sum price. Its key benefit is speed: because design and construction can overlap, work can often start on site sooner.

However, the certainty of that price depends on the contract, the completeness of the design and any changes arising during construction. Variations can lead to additional costs, whilst decisions about materials, construction methods and specifications may be influenced by the contractor’s commercial priorities.

Where designers are novated, their contractual relationship also changes, meaning they generally become responsible to the contractor rather than the client.

The Traditional Route

Under traditional procurement, the client appoints independent architects and consultants to develop the design and prepare detailed tender documents before selecting a building contractor.

Contractors can then price the same design information, allowing their proposals to be compared on a consistent basis.

Following appointment, the design team may be retained to provide project management and contract administration throughout construction.

The advantage is that your priorities stay at the centre of the project. The designers remain contracted to you, contractors compete on the same detailed design, tenders are reviewed for exclusions and qualifications, and an independent Contract Administrator can check costs and changes on your behalf. The trade off is that more design development is usually required before a contractor can be appointed and a construction price agreed. In return, it gives greater certainty over design, quality and cost before work begins.

Construction management offers a further alternative, with the client contracting directly with individual trade contractors. This provides greater direct involvement but also exposes the client to additional coordination and contractual responsibilities.

Why Independence Matters

At Project London, architecture, interior design and project management sit within one practice. We do not undertake construction ourselves, allowing us to remain independent of the appointed building contractor.

For substantial residential renovations, we favour the traditional procurement approach because it provides clients with greater visibility over design, costs and construction quality.

In practice, that independence is reflected in five areas.

1. Competitive Contractor Tendering

Our preferred approach is to prepare detailed tender information and invite suitable contractors to price the same scope of work. We review the submissions, identify exclusions and qualifications, and advise on contractor selection.

If a client has a preferred contractor, they can also be considered within the process.

2. Transparent Costs and Fees

Clients receive clear information about contractor pricing, our professional fees and the financial implications of proposed changes.

We formally monitor construction expenditure throughout the project, providing regular cost reporting.

Our furniture, fixtures and finishes procurement operates on an open book basis, with trade discounts passed on to clients and our procurement fee separately identified.

3. Independent Assessment of Variations

Changes during construction are common, particularly when renovating existing buildings.

When additional works or variations are proposed, we assess the contractor’s quotation against the original contract documentation, applicable rates and pricing provisions.

Where appropriate, we challenge costs, request further information or explore alternative solutions before advising the client.

4. Clearly Defined Professional Roles

Our architectural and project management teams work closely together, providing continuity from design through to construction.

Where appointed as Contract Administrator, we administer the building contract and perform the relevant contractual duties, including assessments and certifications requiring independent professional judgement.

We act as Principal Designer on every project we are appointed to from the outset.

5. Regular Reporting and Oversight

Clients receive regular updates on progress, programme and costs, with construction issues considered alongside the original architectural and interior design proposals.

Our project managers have an architectural understanding of construction, allowing them to engage directly with technical drawings, detailing and site challenges.

This is how we run every project we are appointed to manage. At Sloane Square, a Grade II listed apartment in Chelsea, for example, it meant contract administration, regular site inspections and coordination of specialist consultants, contractors and suppliers throughout the renovation. See how we work here.

At a Glance

Who do the designers work for?

Under design and build, the contractor is responsible for the design, although clients may retain independent advisers. Under traditional procurement, the architectural and design consultants are appointed directly by the client.

How is the construction price established?

Under design and build, the price is agreed with the main contractor. Under traditional procurement, contractors can competitively tender against a developed design.

Who reviews variations?

Under design and build, variations are typically agreed directly between the client and the contractor through the contract. Under traditional procurement, an independently appointed Contract Administrator assesses each change and its cost, and interrogates them where necessary.

How transparent are the costs?

Both routes can provide cost reporting, depending on the contractual arrangements. At Project London, we place particular emphasis on transparent professional fees, contractor pricing, regular cost monitoring and open book procurement.

Our View

Design and build is a legitimate procurement route, particularly where a client values a single contractual point of responsibility.

However, for substantial residential renovations, we believe there are important advantages to retaining an architectural and project management team that is independent of the contractor.

Developing the design in detail before construction, competitively tendering the works and providing independent professional oversight throughout the build creates a clear structure for managing quality, cost and progress.

That is the approach we favour at Project London.

RICS, “Developing a construction procurement strategy and selecting an appropriate route”

Project management services

Let’s get social

Follow us: @proj_london

London interior design living room with sofa, large sash window, coffee tables and elegant styling
Luxury London interior featuring red sofa, internal glazing and custom cabinetry design
Luxury London interior with fireplace, round mirror and bespoke furniture in elegant living space
Luxury London interior design with bedside table, wall sconce and contemporary styling details
Luxury London interior design featuring hallway with staircase, archway and statement chandelier
London interior design living room with sofa, large sash window, coffee tables and elegant styling
Luxury London interior featuring red sofa, internal glazing and custom cabinetry design
Luxury London interior with fireplace, round mirror and bespoke furniture in elegant living space
Luxury London interior design with bedside table, wall sconce and contemporary styling details
Luxury London interior design featuring hallway with staircase, archway and statement chandelier